Im seldom accused of not being clear enough, but maybe I wasnt this time. All I was trying to say is, whose side of the story are you using concerning this incident? Im guessing now it is the side of the five year old which is fine, but id be willing to bet their is at least one other side to this story. I can see the teacher covering her butt, it wouldnt surprise me one bit, but I can also see a five year old maybe getting a little confused with actually happened.