Never have used Patterson or O'Brien. I tried calling Chuck's once with a problem and they were very rude over the phone and made me feel like they didn't have time for me.
A friend recommended BG Auto and Tire in Pontoon. I will never go anywhere else. Brian is a great guy. Reasonably priced. He told me once, "Not trying to gouge people, just trying to make an honest living." My opinion: When you are honest and do good work, it will come back to you ten-fold. He stays busy but always gets us in ASAP depending on the urgency of the problem and how soon we need the vehicle.