There are points for and against Mellon, such as...
For: he got us promoted, steadied the ship and we don't have a big budget this season so mid table may be punching above our weight. He has experience.

Against: Turgid football, fans will be turned off,some very poor results, risk averse and not entertaining which is important when fans are paying £20+. Man city will only charged £18 this weekend.

Some fans may say why risk bringing in another manager that may get us relegated, but why would people presume the new manager would get us relegated? Lots of managers have taken over since our relegation to the 2nd tier in the 90's and didn't get us relegated.
One Mellon fan on the podcast said..if you want entertainment,go to the circus.

So we can't have entertaining football then?