
When this was first reported, I took it at face value, and looked up executive orders and memos. I found they're binding on the executive branch of the government. So, it followed that--if he'd ordered a switch to steam--the executive branch was required to follow that order. That creates a problem with funding.
However, upon reading the actual executive memo itself, no such order was given. It orders a study of the costs, and that a plan be created to switch. That's not the same as ordering the Navy to change the ship to steam. Elements of our press, however, are not capable of the distinction, and once misrepresentation is out there, it gets mindlessly repeated.
See for yourselves. Here's the actual memo. Section 2:
https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2026/08/rebuilding-the-united-states-navy-and-americas-shipbuilding-industrial-base/
Nothing orders the conversion to steam, only looking into how to go about it.
So, there's currently nothing that needs to be stopped. The White House is considering what to do about the information it just got. Congress is now collecting its own information. Should an actual order to switch be given, it has been made clear there will be considerable opposition in Congress, and it is extremely doubtful that funding will be provided. If no actual orders are given to switch, then this is "much ado about nothing," to quote a certain playwright.
The press is so full of nonsense these days. Has filled the country with nonsense. A democracy trying to function on nonsense is not healthy.
Previous Message
A simplification.
There have been bipartisan statements made against it by key senators at the confirmation hearing of Hung Cao for SecNav. A draft of the 2027 defense appropriations bill has ordered a study and report by the Navy comparing the costs of steam and EMALS side-by-side. A group of senators got together and sent a letter of opposition to the president. In general, there is clearly strong opposition. However, I've found no single "bipartisan motion" which has killed it once and for all. What have you read?
I did read that the study the president ordered on costs and "path to steam" was completed, and the results presented to the White House. Only one article looked to offer details of what it showed, and that was paywall protected. Other articles I found just said the White House was reviewing it without any details of its contents. I have read the actual memo. It does not order steam to be used. It directs a written study of costs and creation of a plan to implement the return to steam. That's what the White House is considering...now that they have their report, an order to execute that path could result. If so, then that will require funding, and that will most likely fail. Congress will have their reports and figures stacked against the White House report and figures, and the mood in Congress is clearly not favorable to the president's position.
The president has the results of the study he ordered of the SecDef and OMB. It's not widely released what that shows. It is under consideration. The Appropriations Committee has ordered their own study from the Navy. Verbal bipartisan opposition has been voiced by key senators. A letter of opposition was sent to the president. This is all I have seen.
It certainly does look like it is not going to fly. However, no single motion I have read or can find has stopped it completely. What will ultimately do that (short of the president retracting it) will be no money for steam in the 2027 defense bill. Lots of talk until then, and plenty of pushback against it.
Previous Message
US Navy is not going back to steam catapults the Senate rejected the idea in a bipartisan motion it's good to see intellect prevail
Responses
« Index