
OMB is involved to provide funding data. That, in my mind, is a study. The costs are worked up and presented. Not actionable; there's no money behind it. A bad choice of wording on my part. You're right, it's an order. But, an order which gathers data and makes plans that have no financial means of coming about, to me, is someting more along the lines of a study. And the press, which you say is not the problem here, reports the White House "is considering" the plan-order-study-whatever (without widely disclosing what it actually says. The one place I found which offered that wants money to disclose it. This is certainly their business, and they're entitled. It's not helpful, however.) What is the White House considering, if this is an order? It seems to me they're considering whether to order. Whether to formally go before Congress and get funding, and (try to) make the whole thing actionable.
All I see here was an order to create a plan, which was executed. The plan was created and submitted. Finding its details in the press is a matter of what subscriptions you hold. It's reported that plan is "being considered." Meanwhile, Congress is reported to be widely in opposition to this plan, and funding looks doubtful. All the tweeting and commotion is so much theater. The opposition loves to tout "No kings!" Well, he's not a king, so I've no idea what that means. His every order does not contain substance, and there's a system of checks and balances that is so far still hanging together; Lord hope that continues. It looks like some are trying to make him out to be a king so they can cry that they don't want one. Well, we don't have one. He's only the freaking president.
He ordered a plan be created. It was. Now what? By most accounts, Congress is not impressed, and ultimately won't allow the plan to be carried out. It's a nation of free will. Get ulcers from whatever source pleases you. I figure I only have about 10 more years of good health if I'm lucky, and I don't plan on wasting much of it fretting unnecessarily. I'm going to work on my models. They're fun.
Previous Message
Part of the problem here is that some of the president's orders are issued via Twitter.
This leaves cabinet secretaries, departments and agencies scrambling to meet publicly stated comments presented as requirements without a formal order directing them to act and coordinate their actions. Tough to coordinate mutually supporting activities when a secretary, department or agency has little to go on other than a Tweet.
So let's look at the memo's Section 2 very closely. First, we need to recognize that the memo is a formal, written presidential order. It's not a suggestion or a rally comment. It's a Big Deal because formal orders come with legal consequences to subordinates if they fail to execute them.
The memo begins with: "By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, including section 301 of title 3, United States Code, I hereby direct [order]...." [emphasis mine]
When we look at Section 2, it does not order a study . It orders the creation of an executable plan and explicitly states so. A "plan" and a "study" are very different.
Keep in mind, orders get executed meaning subordinates are expected and required to produce something tangible and/or executable by a specific time or when a specific goal is achieved. They come with a "drop dead date".
"Within 60 days of the date of this memorandum, the Secretary of War, in consultation with the Secretary of the Navy, shall provide to the President, through the Director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and the Assistant to the President for National Security Affairs (APNSA), a plan on the required measures to replace the Electromagnetic Aircraft Launch System and Advanced Weapons Elevators with steam and hydraulic systems for the construction of CVN-81, including timelines and resourcing requirements." [emphasis nine]
The order explicitly states that the "measures" (actions) are required . This is not "study" language. The president is requiring (ordering) that EMALS and AWE be replaced.
For US government purposes, a "plan" is an intention to execute. "Plans" are developed in response to an order or as part of an order. Departments and Agencies create a "plan" so that specific Congressional funding can be requested against it for the execution of the plan, among other executable purposes. "Plans" are not philosophical waxxings.
Looking closely at that section, we see:
Systems Targeted. The directive orders the replacement of both the Electromagnetic Aircraft Launch System (EMALS) and the electromagnetic Advanced Weapons Elevators (AWE) on CVN-81.
Required Replacements. Both technologies must be replaced with traditional steam-powered catapults and hydraulic weapons elevators presumably similar to those used on older Nimitz-class carriers.
Ships Affected. The change begins with the fourth Gerald R. Ford-class carrier, the future USS Doris Miller (CVN-81), which is already under construction at Newport News Shipbuilding. The first three ships in the classthe commissioned USS Gerald R. Ford (CVN-78) and the under-construction USS John F. Kennedy (CVN-79) and USS Enterprise (CVN-80) appear to be exempted and will retain their electromagnetic systems.
60-Day Action Plan. The president gave the Secretary of Defense (referred to in the memo as the Secretary of War), in consultation with the Secretary of the Navy, 60 days to submit a formal execution plan. The plan must be routed through the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and the National Security Advisor, detailing exact engineering measures, timelines, and resourcing requirements.
Back to issuing orders through social media, it is undisciplined leadership to lead a country through social media and Twitter posts. It smacks of his claims that he can declassify documents by just thinking about it.
And since this is how the president operates, the government and its departments and agencies, as well as the media and public, must take his public comments, Twitter commands, rally comments, and Truth Social posts seriously because those agencies have been actually acting on those public statements.
The president has repeatedly, publicly stated verbally and in writing on posts via Truth Social and Twitter that he has demanded and ordered that the Navy kill EMALS in favor of steam. See timeline below of some examples.
Although the media is a problem, the problem here is not the media. The problem here is how the president has been operating with respect to EMALS since 2017.
The "media", did not create this EMALS mess. The president did.
Timeline of Key Presidential Public Statements & Directives since 2017:
May 2017 (Time Magazine Interview). In one of his earliest public critiques, Trump told Time magazine that EMALS was "not good" and lacked power compared to older systems. He stated that you "have to be Albert Einstein to figure it out" and claimed he had already told Navy leaders they were "going to goddamned steam." [emphasis mine]
May 2019 (USS Wasp Speech). Speaking to U.S. service members aboard the USS Wasp in Japan, the president polled the crew on whether they preferred electric or steam catapults. After hearing shouts for steam, he declared, "I think I'm going to put an order : When we build a new aircraft carrier, we're going to use steam," adding that "nobody knows what [electric is] going to be like in bad conditions."
2025 Remarks (Oval Office & Defense Events). Following his return to office, the president renewed his attacks on the system. In Oval Office remarks and speeches to troops, he claimed the magnetic catapults "didn't work," complained that broken components required flying in experts "from MIT," and praised the visual of "beautiful steam pouring off the deck."
July 2026 (Pennsylvania Defense Summit). During a defense summit in Pennsylvania, the president blasted the billions spent on "electronic catapults," calling them overly complex and stating flatly that "they're not good" compared to proven steam systems.
August 13, 2026 (National Security Presidential Memorandum). the president turned his rhetoric into official policy by signing a directive ordering the Pentagon and Navy to scrap EMALS and electromagnetic weapons elevators on future Ford-class carriers, starting with the under-construction USS Doris Miller (CVN-81). In the memo, he argued that "overly complex designs" caused shipbuilding delays and ordered the service to prioritize "proven, reliable, and affordable technologies" like steam and hydraulics.
Responses
« Index