This situation is extremely common in Omaha, especially because roofing here is so closely tied to weather and insurance factors. I was just as confused until I spent time reading new roof cost in Omaha The guide explains that even if two houses look similar, their roofing costs can differ a lot due to hidden variables — past hail damage, number of existing roof layers, roof pitch, and whether decking repairs are needed. What really helped me is understanding how insurance claims and local material requirements play into pricing. After reading it, I realized the quotes weren’t random; they reflected real differences that aren’t obvious at first glance.