You are right, I probably would not want my daughter to box against her, but it wouldn't be my first choice of sport for her anyway. If she had the talent and really wanted to do it, I wouldn't try to stop her.
While I'm fully supportive of Trans folks, I do think if an athlete is taking testosterone to facilitate the transition, it does offer an unfair advantage.
In the case of Khelif, she is not taking testosterone, it's her body chemistry and her chromosomes that make her the way she is. Other female athletes have successfully beat her and I would say there are other female boxers that could likely injure her despite her level of testosterone.
I don't know what the answer is here to be fair to everyone. Should she be prevented from playing sports because of her natural hormone levels? Should she be forced to take female hormones to bring her in line with other female athletes?
If there are going to be some rule on naturally occurring hormone levels, they need to be consistent... what level is too much. If they are going to do that, everyone would have to be tested and there would need to be some kind of option for those that naturally exceed the limit. Do they compete against men or they just can't participate?
Would any of this have been a issue if her opponent had kicked the crap out of her? Again, other women have won bouts against her.
Responses « Back to index | View thread »