What might be a more focused approach to this would be to name the best performance(s) by each of the actors/actresses, which might help order the more expansive lists you created--which is unquestionably a better approach to the matter than what Screen Rant did.
I'll work with the actors for this and devise a numerical approach off the top of my head that might work for this. Let's try this: 5 is a classic performance, 4 is top-notch but not quite iconic; 3 is notable.
So, with that:
Bogart: 5 (Maltese Falcon, In a Lonely Place); 4 (The Big Sleep); 3 (Dead Reckoning, The Enforcer)
Andrews: 5 (Where the Sidewalk Ends); 4 (Laura) 3 (Fallen Angel, Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, Edge of Doom)
Mitchum: 5 (Out of the Past); 4 (Pursued, Angel Face, Night of the Hunter); 3 (Cape Fear, Where Danger Lives)
Ford: 5 (The Big Heat); 4 (Gilda, The Man from Colorado); 3 (Framed, A Stolen Life, Experiment in Terror)
Ryan: 5 (The Set-Up, Crossfire, On Dangerous Ground); 4 (Act of Violence, Bad Day at Black Rock, Clash by Night, Odds Against Tomorrow); 3 (House of Bamboo)
Robinson: 5 (Double Indemnity, The Red House); 4 (Woman in the Window, Scarlet Street, The Stranger); 3 (Night Has A Thousand Eyes, House of Strangers, Key Largo, All My Sons, Black Tuesday)
Lancaster 5 (Sweet Smell of Success); 4 (Criss Cross, The Killers, Brute Force, All My Sons); 3 (I Walk Alone, Rope of Sand)
Widmark 5 (Pickup on South Street); 4 (Night and the City, Kiss of Death, No Way Out); 3 (Panic in the Streets)
YMMV on these evaluations, but it's certainly a starting point for some kind of measure of who had the most impactful roles in noir. I have Ryan with seven 5s/4s; Robinson and Lancaster with five; Mitchum and Widmark with four.
Responses