At Arsenal, again how much say did he have in their recruitment? They look much worse than under Wenger, but was that all his doing as he struggled to assemble a back line to build his time up from.
For me, it's his time at Sevilla that gives me doubts. We all loved his team beating that lot in the final, but a team that won 3 Europa leagues on the spin failed to finish higher than 7th domestically.
Would our fans accept that? Whist we all say we would love to win something, when push comes to shove Everton fans demand league consistency over cup form, as Martinez will tell you.