
The Curse of OAFC
I write this as a thoroughly fed-up Oldham Athletic fan.
Seriously, what does it take for this club to give us something to genuinely cling to? Something more than another false dawn?
I started supporting Oldham during the so-called glory years. Sounds glamorous, doesn't it? In reality, my first real memories were of us somehow surviving Premier League relegation in the Great Escape, before watching us tumble through the divisions, eventually dropping out of the Football League altogether.
35 years of supporting this club, and the overwhelming theme has been one of decline, disappointment and unfulfilled promise.
We finally returned to the Football League, albeit with a fair bit of luck along the way. Last season brought a brief resurgence and a glimmer of hope that we might push towards the play-offs, only for us to wilt away, as seems to be the Oldham way.
Then came the summer. Investment, strengthening, renewed optimism. The bookmakers had us amongst the promotion favourites. We started brightly, and for a moment, you dared to believe.
Yet here we are again, languishing near the foot of League Two.
We're constantly referred to as a "big club", a "sleeping giant". But are we? Because the reality couldn't feel further from those descriptions.
Here's what I genuinely struggle to comprehend.
In 35 years of supporting Oldham Athletic, I cannot remember a single season where we've been the best team in our division. Not one.
In that time, Bury have managed it. Rochdale have. Stockport, Bolton, Wigan, even Accrington Stanley. Clubs we've historically considered rivals, peers, or in some cases smaller than ourselves, have all enjoyed periods of genuine success.
Yet Oldham? We just keep finding new ways to disappoint.
How is it possible to fall so far through the football pyramid and NEVER reach a level where, by virtue of our size, support or resources, we become one of the strongest teams in the division?
At what point does the decline stop and the rebuilding actually begin?
Should we be grateful that we still have a football club? Absolutely. I don't underestimate what the Rothwells have done to save us, and they strike me as decent people who genuinely care about Oldham Athletic.
But surely survival cannot remain the benchmark for success forever?
We have one of the biggest fanbases in League Two. Our away support is phenomenal. Anyone who's stood amongst thousands of travelling Oldham fans will know that feeling, the pride, the noise, the goosebumps of representing your town.
But the supporters cannot keep being the best thing about this football club.
I don't know what Oldham Athletic's realistic ceiling should be anymore. Championship? League One? Perhaps those days are long gone.
But I know where it shouldn't be. Scrapping around near the bottom of the fourth tier of English football.
Something has to change. The current management must surely be questioned, but I think the problems run deeper than whoever happens to occupy the dugout.
Because we've changed managers. We've changed players. We've changed owners. We've changed divisions.
Yet somehow, the outcome always feels the same.
The Rothwells and the Royles are now the people entrusted with changing that. I genuinely want them to succeed, but I'd love to understand what the long-term plan actually is. What are we building? What does success look like? And why should we believe that this time will be any different?
After 35 years, I don't think that's an unreasonable question to ask.
And perhaps the saddest part of all this?
I've got a 10-year-old son. For years, I deliberately kept him at arm's length from Oldham Athletic. He initially supported Manchester City, and I was quite happy to let him. At least he'd experience some success.
Then, foolishly, I took him to Walsall away last season.
Harratt scores in the last minute. Absolute scenes. That feeling only football can give you.
And just like that, he was hooked.
I should have known better.
Because now I look at him, full of the same excitement and optimism I had at his age, and I can't help wondering what exactly I've signed him up for.
Another 35 years of disappointment? Another generation living off the occasional magical moment amongst decades of frustration?
I don't need Oldham Athletic to win the Premier League. I don't even need us to reach the Championship again.
I just want, for once in my life, to watch us be genuinely good at the level we're playing at. To see a season where we're the team everyone else fears, rather than the team everyone else fancies beating.
And more than anything, I want my son to experience something I've never really had in 35 years of supporting this club.
An Oldham Athletic side that gives him a reason to believe, and actually delivers.
Surely that's not too much to ask?
Keep the faith? After 35 years, I'd just like something to have faith in.



Message Thread
![]()
« Index