I'm afraid i'm with frankiefranks on this one, sutton on the bench.
His positioning is suspect and he was skinned several times and that was by non league wingers, so let's take sentiment out of it just for the moment because he's a local lad and would give all for the badge.
If we have any aspirations to get into the 3rd tier of football we have to ask 'is he good enough for that', and the answer is no in my opinion.