I think it would be fascinating to see two versions of the film with Holden and O'Brien switching roles. But I do think Holden is really top-notch here, lots of nuance merged with the flashiness in this part. I think it's one of his best performances.
And maybe at some Noir City Eddie will decide to showcase Alexis Smith, who has a string of excellent noir performances that deserve more focused scrutiny. She threads the needle exceptionally well here...
Responses