
By Stephen Watters
Barnsley, Seaforth Publishing, 2026
Annapolis: Naval Institute Press, 2026
9” x 10-1/2”, hardcover, 160 pages
Illustrations, appendices, notes, bibliography, index. $85.00
ISBN: 9788036198855 (hardback) 97880361988579 (EPUB) 9788036198886 (PDF)
HMS Furious played a seminal role in the first quarter-century of the development of British carrier aviation. During World War I it was the platform for the first deck landing on a British carrier while under way and a famous attack on the Zeppelin sheds at Tondern. After the ship’s major reconstruction in the early 1920s, Furious was used extensively in developing Fleet Air Arm carrier techniques, such as the world’s first night landing in 1926. Furious went on to operate effectively during World War II, including resupply missions to Malta, providing air cover for the Torch landings in North Africa, and conducting two strikes on the battleship Tirpitz in 1944.
I have long been fascinated by the history of this ship ever since I read Commander C.A. Jenkins’s light-hearted autobiography, Days of a Dogsbody (George G. Harrap & Co. Ltd., 1946), as a teenager. Jenkins went on to write a very useful more academic two-part study of Furious for the Warship Profiles series (Profile Publications Ltd, 1972) which remained the only such work devoted to the ship until the publication of this book.
When I learned that Seaforth Publishing was bringing out a book devoted to Furious, I was very excited that the ship might finally receive a thorough modern history. My enthusiasm, however, was tempered after reading the blurb on Amazon: "Subsequent reconstructions added a 300-foot landing deck aft, enabling Furious to conduct the first carrier-launched air attack, against the Zeppelin sheds at Tondern in Denmark in 1915." The operation was in 1918, Tondern was part of Germany until after the two Schleswig plebiscites of 1920, and the landing deck was never used after initial trials in March-April 1918, so had no relevance to the ability to undertake the raid on Tondern (Seaforth itself went one better and substituted 1815 for 1915!!).
Nevertheless, I went ahead and ordered a copy. Aircraft Carrier Furious From Tondern to Tirpitz 1915-1954 is a typical Seaforth product: large format, very clean layout, and replete with generous-sized well-reproduced imagery. Most of the appendices are quite useful, the text has extensive citations, and there is a substantial bibliography.
Overall, the writing is excellent, which one would expect from a retired teacher of history. Unfortunately, it needed the attention of a detail-oriented editor to pick up the numerous errors. For example, on page 39 Furious had no fore-and-aft arresting gear after the 1921-25 conversion but on pages 42-24 there is discussion of the problems this gear caused (it was removed in 1926, but the author misses this). Other examples may be found in discussion of the ship’s anti-aircraft armament in World War II—for example, Furious never had twenty-five 20-millimeter Oerlikons (page 85) nor seven 8-barrelled 2-pounders (page 131).
An inordinate number of the photographs are incorrectly dated. Some examples: Furious did not receive 8-barrelled 2-pounders until the 1930-31 refit but there are quite a few images showing Furious with these weapons that are dated to the 1920s; photographs showing the ship in the camouflage applied in late 1942 are captioned as from 1940 or 1941.
The bibliography is extensive but contains remarkably limited primary documentation. For example, had the author referred to issues of the Admiralty C.B. 01815B—the half-yearly Return of Particulars of War Vessels—at the National Archives, the armament outfit errors would have been avoided. Examination of the bibliography and cross-referencing it to the note citations quickly reveals the biggest single problem with the book: it is heavily and indiscriminately based on secondary sources, not all of which are particularly reliable.
The general reader with limited prior knowledge will learn much from this book. Unfortunately, though it contains much contextual information and many more illustrations, it does not much improve upon Commander C.A. Jenkins’s half-century-old Profiles.
Responses
« Index