I don't know why it would take you to Geocities. Takes me to THIS,
https://open.spotify.com/show/3lrwhe2fO5GjZQKntfJZf6

the Spotify player, on my MAC does the same exact thing, will not play on the regular Chrome Browser Window. The same exact URL, that does work in the Incognito mode,so that makes NO SENSE, same settings, AFAIK.

I use the Incognito window often for several sites, things.