[ Post a Response | North and South ]
Posted by lina on 6/29/2005, 11:14 am, in reply to "Re: Pros and Cons of Book III" --Previous Message--
82.230.219.42
: The only redeeming parts of Book III
: were George and Madeline finding
: each other, (though their love scene
: was a bit over acted, I thought,)
: and the ku klux clan's attack
: backfiring on them. I hated the new
: "Charlie" and why did they
: stop calling him
: "Charles?" He was dull,
: dull, dull. The other Charles had
: fire. This guy was also way too
: young. Willa was boring/not
: believable, and they killed
: Constance and Orry. Bent should
: have stayed dead, then maybe Book
: III would have turned out better. I
: find it hard to believe that Ashton
: didn't even mention her mother being
: dead, but she cried over the house?
: I never knew about the 3rd book, I
: only read the first two, and
: actually never finished the second
: one. I wish I would have skipped
: the third movie as well.
:
:
:
ehhhhh i like willa she was great, she kinda reminds me of augusta maybe because both were first rejected by charles
to me the most disappointment was cooper:the way he totally change his mind, he rejected his family especially marie louise who married a carpetbagger
and the way aston finished was also sad after all she helped fenway for his pianos
billy and brett were forgotten; madeline and george married i didn't really liked that
Message Thread:
« Back to thread