[ Post a Response | North and South ]
Posted by CarylAnne on 2/23/2005, 1:52 pm, in reply to "Re: Pros and Cons of Book III" --Previous Message--
68.248.167.45
After waiting all those years between 1986 and 1994, I couldn't wait for Book III. At the time I was very disappointed, as the rest of us were and are.
I thought Book III was dark, much more violent, rushed, dreary, and ugly. I do watch it when I watch my DVD set of all three books. I sure miss Orry and Constance. I cannot get used to the new Charles or Isabelle. It is humous to see how much the actors who came back have aged in a story that is supposed to take place right after the last one.
I enjoy this website, but can find no others. If anyone knows of other websites, please e-mail me.
thanks,
CarylAnne
: You thought Mont Royal was recreated
: beautifully? One of the reasons I
: hate Book III, is because I
: disagree. No avenue of oaks, trees
: in the middle of the yard, driveway
: bends out of site....it just didn't
: look good at all. It looked like
: the cheapest place they could find.
: Kinda made me wish the clan would
: have taken it over at the end.
:
: My favorite scene by far is the
: Constance death scene.....the only
: bit of acting in the movie. Philip
: is the only one that brought back
: his character....everyone else must
: have forgotten how to act just for
: Book III, especially Madeline.
:
: One good thing about Book 3 is that
: it makes you want to start over
: again.....to see better times....and
: not have a bad taste in your mouth.
:
Message Thread:
« Back to thread