Posted by The Happy Hippy on November 30, 2004, 4:42 am, in reply to "Re: I-Robot review" --Previous Message-- No problems, and your criticism was quite mild compared to some I've received ! I think I enjoyed the film more because (1) I didn't expect it to be "Asimov" in any remote manner, and (2) I went in prepared to be very disappointed, and there's only upwards after that :)
62.252.64.32
: Thanks for clearing that up. Sorry if
: the tone of my post sounded negative
: - it really wasn't meant to (as you
: can tell, it was VERY early in the
: morning and my brain wasn't
: functioning too well!) I do disagree
: with the bulk of your review of the
: film - being a huge sci-fi fan, I
: was very disappointed with the film
: and took umbrage at the use of
: Asimov's name and work merely as a
: marketing tool - but at least we
: agree on Asimov. I am positive I
: would have liked the film much more
: if it had not tried to make a
: distinct link towards Asmiov, but
: had merely stated it was
: 'influenced' by him. A different
: title would have been good, too...
: C'est la vie. Thanks for the
: clarification!
:
: Chuz
Message Thread:
« Back to thread