I bought it the day it came out and loved it despite the bugs. The revamped game released when the original writers of the game opened up the source code was even better - fewer bugs, more ships. The only problem with the latter was the modelling of the newer ships was poor.
These days I satisfy myself with Atlantic Fleet, which is good, but confined to the RN and Kriegsmarine, and Cold Waters which is excellent but has a long learning curve. I'm still on it.
: just run a scenario and see.
: l duel 1 to 1
: Adm Scheer 1944 vs USS Baltimore
: Pretty close ,but I think Scheer has the